Mighty Quinn’s BBQ began as a simple dream shared by pitmaster Hugh Mangum, who first introduced his slow-smoked meats at Brooklyn’s Smorgasburg market in 2011. From that moment, the aroma of hardwood-smoked brisket drew crowds, helping the brand grow into a beloved NYC staple. As the restaurant expanded across the city and beyond, the Mighty Quinn’s BBQ menu evolved with it, blending traditional barbecue techniques with modern flavors that matched what people were searching for online — from “best brisket in NYC” to “authentic slow-smoked barbecue.”
Eventually, their menu gained popularity thanks to signature items like the famous brisket, burnt ends, and hearty sides that feel both nostalgic and timeless.
What many fans don’t realize, however, is that a small secret menu exists — offering off-menu sandwiches and customized meat combinations that loyal visitors quietly rave about.
Yet no matter how big the brand grows, the original brisket that started it all remains the classic centerpiece, still loved and still unbeatable after all these years.
Mighty Quinn’s BBQ Menu (Full Update Menu 2026)
SANDWICHES
Item
Note
Price
Spicy Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy chicken sandwich topped with Chile–Lime Sauce and garnished with pickled cucumbers and slaw.
$11.95
Carolina Mustard Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy chicken sandwich topped with Carolina Mustard Sauce and garnished with pickled cucumbers and slaw.
$11.95
Sausage Sandwich
Smoked beef sausage with a snappy casing and juicy, pepper-garlic bite. Sliced to order.
$12.95
Honey Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy chicken sandwich topped with Honey–Chile Sauce and garnished with pickled cucumbers and slaw.
$11.95
Chipotle BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Hand-pulled, slow-smoked chicken glazed with our Chipotle BBQ Sauce. Served with an optional assortment of pickled veggies & slaw.
$15.50
Smoked Turkey Sandwich
All-natural smoked turkey breast w/ crispy pickled onions and pickled cukes.
$14.95
BBQ Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy chicken sandwich topped with BBQ Sauce and garnished with pickled cucumbers and slaw.
$11.95
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Hand-pulled, slow-smoked pork shoulder glazed with our BBQ Sauce. Served with an optional assortment of pickled veggies & slaw.
$15.50
Brisket Sandwich
Hand-sliced brisket smoked low & slow, piled on a soft roll with pickles & slaw. Sauce on the side for the perfect bite.
$17.95
MEATS
Item
Note
Price
Brisket (GF)
Sandwiches
13.49
Brisket (GF)
Half Pound
14.99
Burnt Ends (GF)
Sandwiches
13.49
Burnt Ends (GF)
Half Pound
14.99
Pulled Pork (GF)
Sandwiches
10.49
Pulled Pork (GF)
Half Pound
11.49
Sausage (GF)
Sandwiches
10.99
Crispy Chicken
Spicy, BBQ, or Honey-Chile
9.99
Spare Ribs
Single Serving (4)
12.49
Spare Ribs
Half Rack (6)
15.99
Spare Ribs
Full Rack (12)
30.99
Wings
Spicy or BBQ (GF) 6 Wings
9.99
Wings
Spicy or BBQ (GF) 10 Wings
14.99
Empanadas
Pork & Beans or Brisket
8.99
Half Chicken (GF)
—
11.99
Brontosaurus Rib (GF)
—
37.99
Rice Bowl
w/ any one side. Add Pulled Pork +2, Brisket or Burnt Ends +3
