Handsome Devil BBQ began as a small dream fueled by big smoke. Founded by pitmaster Ed Randolph in Newburgh, New York, in 2012, the restaurant quickly grew from a pop-up and catering venture into a celebrated name on the East Coast barbecue scene. What started as Ed’s passion for traditional Southern-style smoking turned into award-winning plates that earned Handsome Devil a loyal following and national recognition. Over time, the menu expanded beyond brisket and ribs to include inventive sides, seasonal specials, and even collaborations with local brewers and chefs.
But here’s the twist most fans don’t know—Handsome Devil BBQ also has a secret menu. Tucked alongside its well-loved staples are hidden gems, off-menu treats, and creative spins for those in the know. Still, despite the growth and surprises, the restaurant’s original signature brisket remains the star, a smoky classic that continues to win hearts and plates alike.
Handsome Devil BBQ Menu (Full Update Menu 2026)
Meats
Item
Note
Price
Brisket
Choose from dry rub, BBQ or buffalo.
$0 +
Pulled Pork
Pulled pork portions: 1/4lb to 1lb.
$6 +
Turkey
Tender turkey portions. Choose between 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 3/4 lb, or 1 lb.
$6 +
Ribs
Mild sweet spice
$0 +
Chicken Wings
Choose from dry rub, BBQ or buffalo.
$11.5 +
Wood Fired Half Chicken
Tender wood-fired half chicken seasoned with herbs, accompanied by pickled cucumbers and red onions, served with a side of creamy dipping sauce.
$14 +
Homemade Sausage
Per link, please choose between texas traditional and jalapeno cheddar (jalapeno cheddar is a mild spice).
$8 +
Sandwiches
Item
Note
Price
Brisket Sandwich
Tender brisket slices topped with tangy pickled onions and a drizzle of barbecue sauce, served on a grilled bun.
$17 +
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Tender pulled pork layered on a soft bun, accompanied by pickle slices.
$14 +
Sides
Item
Note
Price
Mac N’ Cheese
St louis ribs
$0 +
Potato Salad
Sides: Potato Salad. Available in small (12 oz) or large (16 oz) sizes.
$5.4 +
Collards with Pork
Collards with pork, available in small (12 oz) or large (16 oz).
$5.4 +
Apple Pie Baked Beans
Apple pie baked beans in two sizes: 12 oz or 16 oz. Sweet, tangy blend with a hint of apple pie spices.
$5.4 +
Carolina Coleslaw
Carolina coleslaw, tangy and crisp. Sizes: 12 oz or 16 oz.
$5.4 +
Thai Chili Crispy Cauliflower
Mild sweet spice
$5.4 +
Honey Butter Cornbread
Per link, please choose between texas traditional and jalapeno cheddar (jalapeno cheddar is a mild spice).
$5.4 +
Specials
Item
Note
Price
Brisket Empanada
A baked pastry turnover typically filled with slow-cooked brisket, caramelized onions, and mild spices.
$7 +
Dessert
Item
Note
Price
Banana Pudding
Banana pudding, Nilla wafers, fresh whipped cream
$8 +
N/A Drinks
Item
Note
Price
Water
Clear, refreshing bottled water.
$3 +
Soft Drinks
Selection of sodas including Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, and Orange Soda.
